Criminal Minds Star Paget Brewster Issues Private Apology After Critic Flap

Criminal Minds: Evolution star Paget Brewster privately apologized to writer Shealynn Scott, a swift and surprising end to a public online spat that flared up over the weekend. The actress initially launched a harsh, condescending attack on Scott's critical coverage of the Paramount+ series, sparking significant backlash from fans and industry peers.
Scott's original piece questioned Paramount+'s decision for shorter seasons of Criminal Minds: Evolution, suggesting it could creatively constrain the show's team. Brewster, known for playing Emily Prentiss, publicly lashed out. Her now-deleted response told Scott she was 'young,' didn't understand how 'bad reviews' could cost jobs, and frankly, that she 'sucked.' This wasn't just a critique; it was an outright dismissal of Scott's professionalism.
The entertainment world quickly rallied behind Scott, decrying Brewster's tone. Faced with widespread condemnation, Brewster issued a public apology, admitting she 'sucked' for her behavior. Scott later confirmed Brewster's private outreach, stating she still loves Criminal Minds and looks forward to covering future seasons. It's a stark reminder of the often-tense relationship between creators and critics, especially in the volatile landscape of social media. A simple conversation, it seems, can often do more than a public tirade.
“A simple conversation, it seems, can often do more than a public tirade.”
Catzye Take
This whole situation highlights the precarious balance between creators and critics in the age of instant online reactions. While a public apology is good, the private reach-out from Brewster is a vital step towards genuine reconciliation. It's a lesson for anyone in the public eye: sometimes, stepping away from the keyboard and engaging directly is the best path.
Newsletter
Stay in the loop
Weekly digest of the top manga & anime stories. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
Want to learn more?
Read our complete Manga guide →






